Skip to content

Fix discrepancy between 'Edit' and 'Update' actions #7484

@MokoJumbie

Description

@MokoJumbie

MokoJumbie created Redmine issue ID 7484

There are several places in grid views in the MODx manager where, when right clicking on an item, the user is presented with the option to 'Update' an item. There are also many other places where a user can 'Edit' an item.

Update can present one of at least two possible resulting actions:
-In System Settings, 'Update Setting' presents a pop-up UI panel to edit the setting definition. One must double click on the value to be edited to present the UI to edit the actual value.
-In Manage Users, 'Update User' takes the user to a new page to edit the values for the user.

Edit actions seem consistent in that they allow to to modify the values for the selected item.

I submit that the meaning of 'Update' in unclear to describe its intended action. I think that the term 'Update' is commonly understood to mean 'Update the application's view to reflect the state of the model' that 'Allow me to Update the values for this item'. In this way, it's closer to 'Refresh' than it is to 'Edit'.

Wouldn't it make more sense to change all uses of 'Update' to 'Edit'? And if an 'Edit' action is going to edit something other than the item's values, perhaps that should be clarified as well, as in 'Edit Setting Definition'?

I'm posting this for discussion in http://forums.modx.com/thread/75425/ui-discrepancy-between-edit-and-update-actions

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    proposalProposal about improvement aka RFC. Need to be discussed before start implementation.type-frontendIssues related to UI/UX issues, mostly about styles and frontend implementations on JavaScript.

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions