Skip to content

Bug: unexpected behavior with seed_random #580

@vkcku

Description

@vkcku
    name = Use(ModelFactory.__random__.choice, ["rule", "group_rule", "misc_rule"])
    color = Use(ModelFactory.__random__.choice, ["green", "red", "purple"])
    type = Use(ModelFactory.__random__.choice, ["input", "checkbox", "list", "link"])

shouldn't ModelFactory.seed_random(10) make the above work?

it only works doing like @Alc-Alc said

    name = lambda: RuleFactory.__random__.choice(["rule", "group_rule", "misc_rule"])
    color = lambda: RuleFactory.__random__.choice(["green", "red", "purple"])
    type = lambda: RuleFactory.__random__.choice(["input", "checkbox", "list", "link"])

But this gives an warning: https://docs.astral.sh/ruff/rules/lambda-assignment/ and it's a little bit ugly.

Originally posted by @JobaDiniz in #578 (reply in thread)

The use of Use doesn't result in deterministic behavior even if one calls BaseFactory.seed_random(some_seed). This is due to how we're implementing seed_random. We create a new Random instance with the given seed instead of reseeding the existing instance. This means that the cls.random.choice function that's referenced is the method associated with the Random instance before we call seed_random. Thus, you don't get the deterministic behavior.

This should be fixed so that seed_instance reseeds the existing random instance we have instead of creating a new one.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions