Add support for reading from replicas in non-`CLUSTER` environments

[jgaskins]

I think we can handle this by accepting a list of URIs in Client#initialize and assigning them at random in the connection pool block.

Thinking something like this:

    # Keep this method signature for backwards-compatibility
    def self.new(uri : URI)
      max_idle_pool_size = uri.query_params.fetch("max_idle_pool_size", "25").to_i
      new([uri], max_idle_pool_size)
    end

    def initialize(uris : Array(URI) = [URI.parse("redis:///")], max_idle_pool_size : Int = 25)
      @pool = DB::Pool.new(
        max_idle_pool_size: max_idle_pool_size.to_i32,
      ) { Connection.new(uris.sample) }
    end

[jgaskins]

I can't remember if this is a thing with Redis, but we may also need to adjust to network topology after we connect in case we don't have all the IP addresses or servers are added/removed after we connect, etc. This is common with a lot of clustered resources, but I don't know if Redis provides this information to clients.

[jgaskins]

Cluster support is added in ca206a7 but it doesn't handle plain replication (single primary shard, many replicas). Redis doesn't call this "clustering" and none of the CLUSTER commands are available in this mode, so I'm not sure what the client abstraction for this particular deployment configuration should be.

And, realistically speaking, do Redis clusters exist in the wild that do simple replication without cluster-mode enabled?

I'm still also unsure that the current abstraction split between Client and Cluster is ideal. The Client maintains a connection pool but the Cluster maintains multiple connection pools. Should the Cluster instead maintain a collection of Clients rather than messing with its own connection pools? 🤔

[jwoertink]

Just wanted to add to this. Our redis env is using cluster mode. stefanwille/crystal-redis#127 There's a docker-compose example in this issue that could be used for some local testing on this.

[jgaskins]

@jwoertink Thanks for jumping in here. If I’m reading that issue correctly[1], this shard already supports that particular type of Redis clustering. This issue is still open only to handle the plain-old-replication form of clustering (via REPLICAOF), which Redis confusingly doesn’t call a “cluster”. This shard does support reading from replicas in sharded clusters, though.

If you use this shard on your Redis cluster (using Redis::Cluster instead of Redis::Client), does it work? For example:

cluster = Redis::Cluster.new(REDIS_URL)

pp cluster.lrange(“thing”, “0”, “-1”)

(pardon the smart quotes in that code, I’m writing on an iPad)

---

[1] The MOVED error is raised when the client talks to the wrong Redis server in the cluster for that key, and is solved by the Redis::Cluster class.

[jwoertink]

oh nice! I'll have to give that a shot and let you know how it goes. That's for the info 🚀

[jgaskins]

Closed by 11cc7a3