P3589 R2 C++ Profiles: The Framework

[wg21bot]

P3589R0 C++ Profiles: The Framework (Gabriel Dos Reis)

[jfbastien]

Profiles were discussed in EWG in Hagenberg on Wednesday:

• P3589 C++ Profiles: The Framework
• P3611 Dealing with pointer errors: Separating static and dynamic checking
• P3081: Core safety profiles for C++26
• P3586R0 — The Plethora of Problems With Profiles

P3589 was merged into P3081, see #2058

[wg21bot]

P3589R1 C++ Profiles: The Framework (Gabriel Dos Reis)

[wg21bot]

P3589R2 C++ Profiles: The Framework (Gabriel Dos Reis)

[hanickadot]

EWG saw this paper on Friday in Sofia.

P3589R2/P3100R2: EWG agrees that Timur's (magic) slide 53 in P3754R0 is a good basis for the core language UB whitepaper, and asks that the Whitepaper editors make it so.

SF	F	N	A	SA
14	28	2	1	0

Result: consensus

P3589R2/P3100R2: EWG encourages more work on P3100R2 and wants a step-by-step systematic review of P3100R2 to do per-clause approval for inclusion in the core language UB whitepaper (in telecons)

SF	F	N	A	SA
15	27	2	0	0

Result: consensus

P3589R2: EWG likes the approach that "C++ Profiles: A Framework" takes, and encourage more work in that direction.

SF	F	N	A	SA
16	14	11	2	0

Result: consensus