Skip to content
This repository was archived by the owner on Sep 5, 2025. It is now read-only.

Conversation

@chochem
Copy link
Member

@chochem chochem commented Jun 24, 2023

This PR removes laser hatch support from the LEG. Multiamp hatches up to 64A will continue to be allowed.

several reasons:

  • The multi is aimed at HV-ZPM while laser is always considered UV+ technology.
  • Laser support on energy production is extremely unbalanced if the numbers are not carefully considered and limitted by something else (which is not the case here)
  • people have figured out how to make up to 136 billion EU/t in ZPM in the extreme. Of course several orders of magnitude less would already be a big problem. by comparison on gets around 1 million eu/t from a single fusion reactor running helium plasma with a large plasma turbine in ZPM. (64A ZPM for one LEG will still be 8 million eu/t!)
  • closes nerf Large Essentia Generator GT-New-Horizons-Modpack#13792

Copy link

@Alastors Alastors left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Please add at least UV (or at most UHV) tier support as has been discussed in Magic-Dev to compromise the laser removal

@chochem
Copy link
Member Author

chochem commented Jun 24, 2023

this was discussed by you, yea. I think HV-ZPM (or EV-ZPM if HV is considered to week) is plenty for single multi.
we also dont really have interesting magic in LuV+ either so luv/zpm is already kinda a stretch and its just gated on the tech side.

Dont get me wrong: balance of LEG is going to be an ongoing topic and not an easy one. but that is not going to be resolved with this PR. This just removes the completely insane laser usage.

When somebody actually puts in the effort to balance the values more, then I guess this can be discussed again. For now I have no interest of expanding the problem of LEG balance to more tiers.

@chochem chochem dismissed Alastors’s stale review June 24, 2023 16:35

out of scope for this PR

@JodieRuth
Copy link

I suggest that Nq fuel and Dyson also remove laser support, which is in line with your philosophy of disgusting players and prolonging game time, constantly killing available options without any compensation

Copy link

@Alastors Alastors left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Oh no you don’t

@JodieRuth
Copy link

LEG need rebalance , not nerf

@Alastors
Copy link

Oh no you don’t

Add the UV support as has been discussed or don’t do it, it’s not that hard

@Alastors
Copy link

We can take this up to a higher level if we need to, adding literally one extra tier is a fair compromise with how many tiers of additional support this pr is removing

@JodieRuth
Copy link

We need more advanced support, UV 64a, and removing the availability of vitam is still very unreasonable, at least allowing us to use all levels of power chambers or lasers with less exaggerated power

@Hikari1nVoid
Copy link

Well from my perspective we need zpm+ dilusion cells up to large Nq reactor tier(so ev-uev)before applying 64a limitation since 64A is FAR LESS than enough in mid-late game base.

@Alastors
Copy link

Well from my perspective we need zpm+ dilusion cells up to large Nq reactor tier(so ev-uev)before applying 64a limitation since 64A is FAR LESS than enough in mid-late game base.

I fully agrée actually, I do think we should add UV and UEV, but if push comes to shove I would be happy just adding at least UV as has been discussed.

It's rather insulting to see a requested change get nuked without consideration for what's been discussed, reminds me of a situation that recently happened with Ender

@boubou19
Copy link
Member

@Alastors It's not reasonable. It's been pending since a year, to the point we thought it was already merged. So if you want extend it to UV, feel free to do it in another PR. The PR scope is clearly defined in the opening message by Chochom.

@Alastors
Copy link

@Alastors It's not reasonable. It's been pending since a year, to the point we thought it was already merged. So if you want extend it to UV, feel free to do it in another PR. The PR scope is clearly defined in the opening message by Chochom.

And it never happened since a year, but it's an absolutely fair rebalance in the face of this massive nerf, but yeah sure give me a moment

@Alastors
Copy link

@Alastors It's not reasonable. It's been pending since a year, to the point we thought it was already merged. So if you want extend it to UV, feel free to do it in another PR. The PR scope is clearly defined in the opening message by Chochom.

#169

it was literally only changing a 7 to an 8, that's hardly out of scope.

@chochem
Copy link
Member Author

chochem commented Jun 24, 2023

do the blocks already exist? and what about balance numbers?

@Alastors
Copy link

do the blocks already exist? and what about balance numbers?

the only thing that's changing is extending the max tier diffusion cells to UV, they're already expensive as is, but changing the recipe is "out of the scope"

@chochem
Copy link
Member Author

chochem commented Jun 24, 2023

well I am gonna stay out of that. but I guess am now allowed to dismiss the request changes again?

@Alastors
Copy link

well I am gonna stay out of that. but I guess am now allowed to dismiss the request changes again?

I'll dismiss them for now

@Alastors Alastors dismissed their stale review June 24, 2023 17:36

stale for now

@Alastors
Copy link

well I am gonna stay out of that. but I guess am now allowed to dismiss the request changes again?

I'll dismiss them for now

the UV LEG needs to get approved though

@desagas
Copy link

desagas commented Jun 24, 2023

As an outsider, just getting into HV in my first play through, I hate packs that remove functionality or alternatives because of balance reasons. I agree with the original post that that brought about this change: it is better to rebalance it than it is to remove it, it keeps the options open for people who want to play different ways.

@JodieRuth
Copy link

In fact, the earliest laser can be used in the LuV stage, during which UV grade boron glass can be solidified for use in the Lamberton supercapacitor library. In the ZPM stage, laser vacuum tubes can be made using assembly machines added by GT++, which is not exclusive to UV+. The ZPM stage also has an active transformer from TecTech to cooperate with it

@chochem
Copy link
Member Author

chochem commented Jun 25, 2023

@desagas the multi is not being removed, not even close lol. it is still quite strong after.

Copy link
Member

@greesyB greesyB left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I am in favor of this. Even after this nerf LEG is usable from HV-ZPM, which is a very long time for a single powergen method.

@Alastors
Copy link

Alastors commented Jun 26, 2023

I am in favor of this. Even after this nerf LEG is usable from HV-ZPM, which is a very long time for a single powergen method.

Would you mind also approving its sister pr

@greesyB
Copy link
Member

greesyB commented Jun 26, 2023

Would you mind also approving its sister pr

I don't really agree that UV hatches are necessary so I won't be the approver, but I won't get in the way if someone else wants it.

@chochem
Copy link
Member Author

chochem commented Jul 1, 2023

dream told me to merge. so this is admin approved

@chochem chochem merged commit 7420285 into GTNewHorizons:master Jul 1, 2023
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

nerf Large Essentia Generator

7 participants